Supplier tasting notes set a rough flavor expectation; they do not identify these roast traits. The cacao sold under one origin can change across lots and harvests, so diagnose the bag you are roasting. You can check size and raw astringency before roasting. Learn the other traits from a baseline and comparison roasts, starting with every box unchecked.
- High acid
- With your recipe and refining held steady, the baseline chocolate tastes sharply sour or vinegary rather than pleasantly bright. Do not infer this from fruit-forward tasting notes alone.
- Low flavor potential
- Once the baseline is neither sharply acidic nor raw and puckering, its chocolate and origin aromas still taste faint. A short catalog flavor list does not prove low potential.
- Heat-tolerant
- Compare the baseline with a deeper roast. Check this if the deeper trial gains chocolate and browned flavors without a large rise in harshness or bitterness.
- Nut-sensitive
- Compare the baseline with a darker roast. Check this if pleasant nut notes quickly become harsh or bitter. A supplier’s “nutty” tasting note is not enough by itself.
- Low raw astringency
- Chew a raw nib. Check this if it causes little of the dry, puckering feeling of strong tea. This is separate from sourness.
- Small beans
- Count the beans in 100 grams and compare that count with lots you normally roast. More beans means a smaller average bean; there is no useful universal cutoff.